Mistakes, misunderstandings and misdiagnoses in veterinary ophthalmology

Posted on August 25, 2016 by David Gould

Ophthalmology is a discipline that confuses and sometimes intimidates vets in first-opinion practice. In reality, there is no great mystery to clinical ophthalmology. True, there is an equipment issue; for conditions such as glaucoma, no matter how much an eye ‘looks’ glaucomatous, without a tonometer you are never going to make an accurate diagnosis, let alone know whether your treatment is effective at lowering the intraocular pressure. But, diagnostic equipment aside, ophthalmology is primarily a discipline of pattern recognition - once you have seen a particular condition you tend to remember it and recognise it the next time a similar case presents to you.

There are, however, a number of mistakes or misunderstandings that seem to crop up fairly regularly in first opinion practice.

Misdiagnosing corneal oedema

An example of a common misdiagnosis is the failure to identify the presence of corneal oedema. One of the mechanisms for maintaining transparency of the normal cornea is its relative dehydration. This is achieved by a combination of a hydrophobic epithelium which repels ocular surface water, and a sodium/potassium ATPase pump system within the corneal endothelium, which actively removes water from the corneal stroma. A failure in one or other of these systems (either breakdown of the corneal epithelium, such as corneal ulceration, or reduction of the endothelial pump mechanism) leads to corneal oedema.

However, because oedema gives the cornea a cloudy appearance, this condition is too often mistaken for keratitis; a misdiagnosis that can actually be a sight-threatening.

Corneal oedema or keratitis?

Keratitis is usually associated with ocular surface disease such as corneal ulceration and keratoconjunctivitis sicca. Whilst these are serious conditions in their own right, they are (with the exception of deep ulcers) not usually an emergency requiring urgent diagnosis and treatment if sight is to be saved.

Corneal oedema, on the other hand, can be a sign of severe intraocular disease that, if missed, can lead to permanent blindness – examples including glaucoma, lens luxation, or anterior uveitis.

But whilst corneal oedema and keratitis can look similar at first glance, they are actually quite different in appearance. Corneal oedema gives a characteristic ‘stippled’ appearance (which often reminds me of the stippling on the surface of an orange).

Corneal oedema by David Gould
Figure 1: Corneal oedema (in this case due to lens luxation)
Note the stippled appearance characteristic of corneal oedema
Corneal oedema associated with a deep corneal ulcer by David Gould
Figure 2: Corneal oedema associated with a deep corneal ulcer

This stippling is due to hydration of the stromal collagen fibrils, which then swell and separate, scattering light to cause this characteristic appearance.

Compare this to non-ulcerative keratitis (Figure 3) which also causes corneal clouding, but without the stippled appearance, and often with additional signs such as vascularisation or pigmentation.

Chronic non-ulcerative keratitis by David Gould
Figure 3: Chronic non-ulcerative keratitis in a cat with FHV-1

Confirming diagnosis of corneal oedema

So if you see the tell-tale stippled appearance of corneal oedema, first perform fluorescein-staining to rule out corneal ulceration, and then look for an intraocular cause, with particular emphasis of identifying potentially serious and blinding causes such as glaucoma, lens luxation or anterior uveitis. Thus pattern recognition, in this case the ability to recognise the typical appearance of corneal oedema, is vital if these conditions are to be recognised and treated in time.

Avoiding common ophthalmology mistakes

I will be addressing the most common ophthalmology mistakes and misunderstandings on BVA’s ophthalmology course on 4 October. Questions we will be addressing include:

  • Do all dogs and cats with corneal ulcers require prophylactic antibiotic eye drops?
  • If so, must we use a veterinary licensed product over an unlicensed antibiotic eye drop?
  • Are topical serum drops beneficial?
  • Do NSAIDs delay healing?
  • When should you perform a grid keratotomy, and more importantly, when should you not?
  • What about corneal repair gels - do they work?

Please note this course is now fully booked. If you would like to be added to the waiting list please email events@bva.co.uk.

More on this topic 

David Gould

Written by David Gould

BSc (Hons), BVM&S, DVOphthal, DipECVO, MRCVS RCVS and European Specialist in Veterinary Ophthalmology

David worked in general practice before completing a PhD in the molecular genetics of inherited eye diseases of dogs. After finishing a 3-year clinical residency in veterinary ophthalmology, he became a lecturer in the subject at the University of Bristol. David joined Davies Veterinary Specialists in 2003, where he leads the ophthalmology referral service. David is a Director at Davies Veterinary Specialists.