The veterinary voice for animal welfare: reflecting on BVA’s updated Animal Welfare Strategy
11 Jul 2025
Ahead of this week’s BVA Congress session on the decision-making around neutering cats and dogs, Dr Rachel Dean FRCVS, EBVM Consulting Ltd, outlines how the changing evidence base for neutering must inform, not make, clinical decisions.
Evidence-based veterinary medicine (EVBM) is a way of thinking and practising that enables transparency and choice to maximise the benefits of our decision making for the animals we treat. EBVM is not just about evidence, it’s about how we choose to combine it with our clinical expertise in the context of the animal and its owner.
However, while EBVM is talked about a lot, it often suffers from an identity crisis. Many of us practice in an evidence-based way as it involves combining whatever evidence is available with our clinical expertise placed in the context of the animal and client combination presented. This is the triad of EBVM: Clinical Expertise, Context and the Evidence, and we need all three.
But sometimes EBVM is talked about only in terms of the evidence, which can lead to comments like:
‘Well, the evidence says this is the right thing to do…’,
Or, ‘We don’t have evidence for that…so we can’t do it’,
Or, ‘Well this paper says we have to….’,
This ‘tyranny of the evidence’ is real. Clinicians worry about not ‘following’ the results of a study or a guideline because that will be ‘wrong’. We also have situations where it is felt that the evidence says we must do something. When a new paper or piece of information is published, we sometimes act on the results of just this rather than putting it into the context of the whole evidence base and our clinical expertise. One paper does not change the world. One paper is just a piece of the jigsaw, and we need to incorporate this with existing knowledge and clinical judgement before applying it to our clinical context.
Sometimes the opposite happens and there is no evidence. This can be interpreted as ‘we are not being evidence based’ and therefore we can’t or mustn’t do something- this is not the case. It is important that we understand that part of being a EBVM practitioner is understanding what is and is not scientifically founded.
When it comes to the tyranny of evidence in clinical practice, the subject of neutering cats and dogs is a prime example. Our understanding of and the evidence base for the potential positive and negative effects of neutering on dogs’ and cats’ physical, emotional and cognitive health has developed significantly in the last 20 years. When and how we neuter cats and dogs has changed as a result.
During this time, however, there has been much discourse about when it is ‘right’ and when it is ‘wrong’ to neuter, and whether we should do it at all. Whilst the evidence base has grown, the ‘jigsaw’ is far from complete and every time we change practice, the evidence needs change too. Frequently during this period articles, scientific papers, guidelines and expert opinion have ‘told us what to do’ and if we make different choices, we may cause harm – but it’s not that black and white and never will be.
A single paper that states the age at which we should neuter a dog with limited choice should be placed very carefully in the context of the clinical situation. It does not create a ‘rule’ to be followed. A clinical guideline with no choices in it is not helpful for such a complex decision. A practice or national policy still needs to be adapted to a particular case or local setting – it is not a rulebook to be followed and should be a guide that helps.
Like many other clinical areas, we also have many evidence gaps in our knowledge about neutering – should we neuter large breed cats later? Does neutering significantly increase the risk of certain neoplasia in some or all breeds?
It is crucial that we understand the extent of the evidence base and where knowledge gaps lie if we are to improve our evidence-based decision making around neutering. When we know what important evidence is missing, we can make a noise about it, prioritise it and find a way to get the science we need. And, in the absence of scientific evidence, a robust audit of clinical outcomes when we change the way we neuter animals in clinical practice is very valuable evidence in itself.
As vets in small animal practice, how do we apply the principles of EBVM to neutering decisions? Join me, Westway Vets clinical director Caroline Scobie, and BVA Junior Vice President Fieke Molenaar at this week’s BVA Congress for a discussion on this relevant topic.
The session will focus on a case-led approach to neutering decision making, moving beyond policy into real world practice, showing how vets can balance evidence, risk, owner priorities, and practical realities when advising clients.
You can expect the panel to dig into the grey areas of neutering decision making, cover how you can balance evidence, risk and owner priorities to inform individualised and defensible decisions, and ask the question: What would you do if you were presented with one of these cases?
Neutering: A case-led approach to decision making in everyday practice takes place at BVA Congress on Friday, 20 November from 3.15pm-4.15pm.
Get tailored news in your inbox and online, plus access to our journals, resources and support services, join the BVA.
Join Us Today